Casper Vs. Layla: Head-to head Mattress Comparison

TLDR;

Here, we’ll compare Layla and Casper, highlighting each mattress’s features and offerings.

casper vs layla

The mattress industry has been growing at a steady rate, and while that means more choices for consumers, it also means more struggles trying to find the right fit. Between lists of features and product specifications that have no bearing on how well you sleep on your mattress, there’s a lot to deal with when shopping for a new mattress.

Read on for more about both brands and their respective collections, or skip to the summary section, if you’re in a hurry.

But we’re here to help! Our team has compared Casper and Layla mattresses to give you an overview of what each collection offers. With our help, you’ll be able to determine which bed is right for you. Casper has three collections spanning a basic model, a comfort-focused mid-range bed, and a higher-level ergonomic model. Layla has dual-sided beds which allow for customization of your sleep surface with a quick flip. Here’s more on how these two brands stack up.

​Who Is It For?

Casper’s Essential mattress is the entry-level memory foam bed for a variety of sleep scenarios. The mid-level bed packs more memory foam with plenty of support, but the Wave model is ideal for those with back pain or positioning issues. Our team highlights the Wave as a favorite for its ergonomics and its relative affordability.

Layla mattresses have flippable firmness options—each side is a different firmness—and their copper-infused materials help reduce allergens in your sleep area. Copper also has heat-diffusing properties, meaning Layla is a great choice for warmer sleepers.

Layla mattress

The Collections

Casper has three mattress collections (Essential, Casper, and Wave) while Layla has one option.

Size

Casper Essential PriceCasper PriceCasper Wave Price

Layla Price

Twin$350$595$1,095$499
Twin XL$400$645$1,195$599
Full$500$895$1,695$799
Queen$600$995$1,995$899
King$725$1,195$2,395$999
CAL King$725$1,195$2,395$999

Construction of the Mattresses

Casper’s mattresses all use memory foam construction in different layers. The Wave has five layers, including pressure point reduction foam, ergonomic lumbar support, and open-cell cooling foam. The Casper has four layers of foam that focus on comfort, and the Essential is streamlined with three layers of foam and a bouncy top surface.

Casper notes that its open-cell foam is what helps keep sleepers cool, and a zip-off cover makes cleaning easy. Pressure relief and durability are top traits of all the materials Casper uses.

Layla’s mattresses incorporate copper for its antibacterial and cooling properties, which our team found to be impressive. The bed also has four foam layers, with the top layer containing that copper-infused foam component.

Convoluted foam helps enhance airflow for further cooling, and the “bottom”—depending on how you look at it—is firmer than the flip side. This “flippable” feature is what makes the Layla ideal for people who like to rotate their mattresses. Many memory foam mattresses are one-side-only, but Layla just made their beds firm on one side and softer on the other.

Layla mattress structure

Trial Period and Guarantee

Casper has a 100-night sleep trial so you can test out any of their beds before committing completely. The sleep trial also includes any bedding or frames you purchased with the mattress. If you want to return the bed, the company will come to pick it up for free and donate it to a charity whenever possible.

If you keep the bed, a 10-year warranty applies, and this protects against sagging and other material failures.

Layla’s bed comes with a 120-night sleep trial, and the company also donates gently used beds to charity when customers return them. Their process is fee-free too; just call them to send the mattress back if you’re dissatisfied.

If you keep the Layla, a lifetime warranty applies. Our team found this impressive since not many mattress brands are willing to back their products for life. The warranty covers things like sagging, indentations in the foam, and more.

Firmness Level

Casper’s three mattresses range from bouncy low-firmness (the Essential) to medium-firmness (the Casper and Wave), and there’s no room for customization. However, regarding support, you can’t go wrong with a mid-firm mattress.

With Layla, however, you get two firmness choices in one mattress. One side is a medium-soft firmness and the other is firm, giving sleepers a customizable experience, plus the opportunity to flip the bed for a softer sleep if they’re in pain or need more profound sleep recovery.

Comfort

Casper’s Essential mattress is a bit bouncy, making for a comfortable and plushy rest. The Casper and Wave beds are less plush but offer the same level of contouring and support, making them two of our more dependable picks when it comes to comfort.

Layla’s foam mattress is kept cooler thanks to that copper addition, and we also liked that the copper added a level of antimicrobial protection. For people with allergies, there’s nothing less comfortable than sneezing all night or feeling like you’re sleeping on a pile of dust mites. With the Layla, the copper infusion helps alleviate stress and keep you cool while you rest.

Smell Effect

Neither Casper nor Layla have a chemical smell; Casper may have a bit of an odor thanks to the adhesive they use. However, the glue is non-toxic and water-based, so it’s less of a chemical concern as simply an acquired smell. Just open a window, however, and you’ll be all set to sleep the night away.

Regarding odor, Layla even notes that its mattresses have “no bad, smelly stuff inside.” The company holds a CertiPUR-US certification and uses no formaldehyde or flame retardants.

Motion Isolation

Layla has impressive motion isolation, especially given its contouring features and firmness options. Check out a YouTube video if you don’t want to take our word for it! If you tend to toss and turn at night (or if your partner does), Layla could help you both rest a little easier.

As far as Casper, their beds aren’t ideal for motion isolation. While the Essential boasts that it’s “bouncy,” the Wave is a bit more resistant to motion transfer. However, Layla still receives our highest ranking for motion isolation overall.

The Ordering Process

Ordering with Casper is as simple as choosing your mattress type and size, then checking out with your online cart. However, you can also find Casper products in-store at Target and Casper’s own retail stores. So if you really feel like you must test out a mattress in person, Casper is one you can do so with.

Ordering with Layla is simple as well because there is only one collection with six basic size options. Shipping is free with Casper, but Layla does charge for shipping to Hawaii and Alaska. Customers in the contiguous 48 states receive free shipping, but those in Hawaii, Alaska, and also Canada must pay a $125 shipping fee. For Canada, this covers shipping duties and other international fees.

Casper Mattress
Layla Mattresses

Delivery and Packaging

Casper mattresses arrive straight to your door and depending on your location, White Glove delivery service may be available at no additional cost. Casper will also remove your existing mattress at no extra charge.

Layla mattresses arrive in compact boxes that weigh between 50 and 90 pounds, depending on the size of your mattress. Delivery typically takes up to five business days, and your package will come straight to your front door. Layla beds ship from a facility in Phoenix, Arizona.

Conclusion

So how do I choose?

In the Casper vs Layla question, there’s no right or wrong answer. Each brand has its own features and benefits. It’s just a matter of seeing which one is going to be right for your body structure, sleeping habits, and budget.

Let’s start with selection: For mattress buyers entering the market for the first time, Casper is a great cost-effective choice. There are three memory-foam-based mattress types to choose from, ranging from the most basic to the more advanced Wave model. On the other hand, Layla only offers one mattress type, but it is a flippable mattress, meaning you are actually purchasing two ways to sleep. Layla also offers another important feature – mattresses made with copper-infused materials, which helps to prevent allergies and effectively diffuses heat. This is definitely a bonus for sensitive sleepers.

How about firmness? Casper offers three levels of firmness, from soft and bouncy to medium firmness. Layla’s flippable mattress is medium-soft on one side, and firm on the other, making it a great choice for sleepers who have changing needs.

And what about price? Casper’s Essential and Casper mattresses are a similar price point to Layla, while Casper’s advanced Wave mattress sits at a higher price point. Affordability and value for money are the name of the game for both brands.

When comparing Casper vs Layla, there are some good options here for people in the entry to mid-level market, with both brands offering flexibility in one or more areas of firmness, comfort and price.

Lee Levy

Lee Levy

Lee is an experienced reviewer and passionate about trying new products. She is a side sleeper and always looking to ways to avoid back pains in her sleep. Lee is a mom for two little princesses and a devoted wife, living in Brooklyn, NYC.